Ethical Mirror: Gaze Theory and Tom Waits' "I Never Talk to Strangers"


I have always loved Tom Waits' bantering barroom drama  “I Never Talk to Strangers."  The song depicts the coming together of two strangers in a bar in some nowhere/everywhere of modern culture.  The banter-turned-discourse progresses through various stages, from an initial aloofness and combativeness (“Do you really think I'd fall for that old line/I was not born just yesterday”), to a tentative vulnerability (“You're looking for someone to take the place of her”), and finally to the acknowledgment of an intimacy that pre-existed the two participants’ coming together, an intimacy of recognition of the Other, a recognition based in discourse (“That we all begin as strangers/Just before we find/We really aren't strangers anymore”).

There are a few different paths the song meanders down which I find interesting. The first is the space the exchange takes place in; the second is the flow of the exchange itself, namely from combativeness to an acknowledgement of shared humanity; the third is the nature of the final stage of the exchange, rather than the banter the song beings with, it is an authentic, honest discourse between two humans the songs leaves its listener with.

The first path deals with the space the song occupies, namely a bar.  The space has three occupants (or at least only those occupants are revealed in the work): a heartbroken man (sung by Tom Waits) attempting to start up conversation with a woman (sung by Bette Midler) who, too, suffers hurt through love, and a bartender, whose only presence is a brief mention at the very start of the song, and whose absence from, or rather leaving of, the conversation actually signifies the parameters of the space the man and woman communicate through.  For the space of the bar, the space of the song, is, by song’s end, an intimate space.

The intimacy-becoming of the space allows for the full development and revelation of what it is to be human.  As the intimacy of the space comes into being, the participants move from an alienated hostility to a profound and shared humanity.  This movement entails the creation and display of a broad range of human emotions: banality, despair, jadedness, anger, bitterness, self-effacement, aggressiveness, sorrow, understanding, compassion, empathy and connectedness.  This evolving space of intimacy allows for the emergence of the human potential in its full capacity, which moves the space out of the (non-intimate) /public space/, seen here in the normative performance of societal mandated gender stereotypes of a male instigator and a female conditionalizer.  The public space is established in the first line of the song by the inclusion of a third party observer, the bartender, who acts as a mediating agent on the interaction between the two, thus the bartender is a /public mediator/ (as is the internalized “bartender” of the male and female stereotypes). However, after the bartender-as-public-mediator is introduced, he is instantly drawn away from the space, retreating from the space (he’s never brought up again as a participant, and we can assume he has drifted down the bar to wipe glasses.).  The bartender’s absence allows the space to reconfigure itself into something new.  The space, absent the public mediator who possesses the public gaze, loses the objectifying quality of /public space/, losses the objectifying quality of the mediating, or managing gaze of an indifferent public participant (a participant who is both object and objectifier).

As the public gaze (the objectifying gaze) begins to fade, the public objects of “man” and “woman” begin to shed their “objecthood,” their abstractions, and become more solidly Subjects, which is to say, they become the Subject-through-interaction, an actual Subject, negotiated with another Subject, claiming their Subjecthood via the negotiation of “humanhood” (being-the-Subject/becoming-the-Subject).

In this possibility of negotiation the human is created, and a level of /discourse/, rather than mere banter reached. Discourse is grounded in the Subject sees Subject Gaze.  A gaze of Freedom, achieved in a private space among private persons as Subjects.

Here, I would like to pause and backtrack just a bit to unpack some notions of various sorts of gazes. First, it should be noted that the gaze is not “of” the eye (“seeing” will be used as a term of convenience).  In the same manner that Emmanuel Levinas’ concept of the “face” is not “of” the face, rather the “face” is of the unrepresentable representation that constitutes the human’s absolute unrepresantable essence. The gaze is not of the eye, it is rather, to put it metaphorically, a “door” through which possibility is either granted access or denied.  As such I venture forth with the idea of four different gazes:

1. Object sees Object
a. (Objectifies)
b. (Public gazes upon Public)

2. Subject sees Object
a. (Conditionalizes, when the Subject has the prerogative and power of granting access to the private realm)
b. (Private gazes upon Public)

3. Object sees Subject
a. (The Object recognizes the Freedom of the Subject, as the public object delineates the Subject itself to itself, but the Subject is a limited Subject )
b. (Public gazes upon Private)

4. Subject sees Subject
a. (Freedom)
b. (Private gazes upon Private)
c. (Discourse)

The song’s movement begins to trace these four gazes, ending in the fourth gaze which is “discourse.”

Discourse is the possibility of negotiating one’s Subjecthood, fully, via a private experience with the Other, free from the normative structures and restrictions of the public, objectifying gaze.  Discourse is a stance of, among other things, vulnerability, for vulnerability is an openness.  And while the third variety of gazes allows the Subject to operate outside of the regulations and managerial normatives of the Public, thus being able to claim a low-level subjectivity, the third gaze is, however, still a gaze of exploitation, where the Subject achieves a limited Subjecthood based on the mandate that the Public object /remain/ an object.  This results in a limited Subjecthood due to a lack of openness to the Other, as a Subject.  This openness is only present in the final “discursive” gaze, in which the Other is able to demonstrate its Subjecthood honestly, and in so doing opens both Subjects to exist fully as Subjects, as they become open to their selves through actual, authentic negotiation, and thus realization, of their Subjecthood, rather than using (public) objects as a sort of echo-location of a Subejcthood, which this echo-location doesn’t allow an openness, rather simply results in a subjective solipsism.

Tom Waits’ “I Never Talk with Stranger” is a wonderful demonstration of the limits of public space in becoming a fully realized Subject.  The song details the movement away from the obviousness of mandated opinions and speech acts (the “banter”) towards a space in which reality, life, understanding, knowledge, truth is worked out openly, honestly, and creatively between vested Subjects engaged to, and with, each other, in freedom granting exploration of the human.



Comments