The Ghost of Lacan's Desire in Joseph Sheridan Le Fanu's "An Account of Some Strange Disturbances in Aungier Street"

Editor's Note: The following are excerpts from a letter received from the illustrious Dr. Winston Sebastian Sinclair III, who we are lucky to call friend.  The excerpts are brief but enlightening.

“…just yesterday, in that little boat house on the sands of Begur, you remember, I was reposed, ruminating upon Dick’s missing story of Nicholas Spaight, and piddling around with the notion of the das Ding of Monsieur Lacan. Das Ding is the realm of the Real.  But, the Real, as das Ding is always lost to us, a lost object which must be incessantly rediscovered. As such the Subject is always kept at moving around the object of desire without ever attaining it.”

“…with Dame Dannie’s swimmingly insistence that Lacan…[and his] reference to courtly love and the movement toward, but ultimately unattainable of, the Thing, the woman, the Lady. The urge towards das Ding, is a structure around a hole (the vagina in courtly love), an emptiness…”

“…the crux of the mystery of le Fanu’s tale is: why did the judge hang himself.  The answer, that motivation is a hole, a gap, in the story, a gap which Dick (now symbolic: penis) attempts to fill by visiting the servant’s old mother (the universal mother figure, the universal void, the void of signification of the Object).  But, no matter if Dick’s knowledge is satisfied, the hole must remain for the reader, and thus Dick's knowledge is kept from the reader…"

“…yes, I agree, this does add a new dimension to the crooked/limp neck of the judge as he vainly (impotently) attempts to fill the dark holes of the house (the lobby and alcove) even in death.”

“…wonderingly, as such then the house becomes the Lady of Courtly Love, which is to say the house is feminine….then, the only other feminine presence is the housekeeper’s daughter.  Thus,it is the daughter then that haunts the house, rather she is the house that is haunted, the house of haunted.  As the house, she holds, imprisons the judge captive in her…of course, the anthropomorphizing of the house has with its windows as “eyes” and its “hole,” i.e. alcove (where the limp maleness dwells).”

“…the idea of male impotency, via the limpness of the judge’s neck, and the female house. But, yes, “Tom” is closest to the hole, the alcove, not Dick, but the specter of impotency drives Tom to run away from the feminine back to Father’s house, back to the Name-of-the-Father, ala Lacan…internalizing the Name-of-the-Father, for Lacan, guaranteed participation in the broader arena other than the family, and was for him, Lacan, an vital component of  being sane: Tom’s insanity, his actual seeing of the judge, rather than Dick’s witnessing of representations of the judge, is a dissolving of that father internalization, and thus his running back to the family, to be re-invested with the Name, so as to once more gain his sanity and position in Society."

“…Further, Dick is immediately wary of the room with the alcove- but upstairs he is kept up at night sweating due to the figments of a bear creature and a rat- two aspects of animal sexuality… And of course, actual limp-necked Judge hasn’t reached him yet, the impotence is figure has not reached him."

“...the judge has a sexual relationship with his housekeeper, with undertones to a rape.  A daughter is born, a few years the judge kills himself using her rope…was the suicide due to the daughter, for after he dies he haunts her, essentially killing her? The daughter dies and ends up becoming the haunted house, entrapping the judge inside her.  The young girl imprisoned him because he haunted her, killing her, and he haunted her because she had something to do, not directly, she was too young, something to do with his hanging…”

“ …who was Nicholas Spaight?....was Nicholas Spaight falling in love with the daughter's mother? Did he discover the truth of the daughter’s fathering, and strike out at the judge? Making a murder look like a suicide?”

“…and then of course there is a series "strange occurrences" occur, a spate (Spaight) of occurrences leading up to  Dick and Tom taking possession of the house and having their own occurrences, one with representations of the absence (Dick's experience), and one with the actual absence (Tom's experience, which of course can only reach us through a representation (via Dick's story) which perpetuates the absence ala das Ding. (and even Dick's representation (thus perpetuation) of the absence, has a further representation of absence: the missing Spaight story))”

“…concluding of course, with the he house (the "girl) being burned down.  Was the judge's intention to have the house/girl burned down, freeing him, thus freeing himself?"

“…the undertaker, like you wrote, the one who puts the dead to rest rebuilds just a house, rather than resurrecting the girl, and in that rebuilding of just a house, he puts the phantom of the girl to rest.”

Comments