A Deathly Order: The Problem of Evil in Edward Gorey's "The Gashlycrumb Tinies"


Much has been written about the repeated trope of deceased parents, especially Mothers, in Disney films.  The research study Death in Disney Films: Implications for Children's Understanding of Death examines the influence Disney’s portrayal of death in its films has on children’s concept of death.  Reading through the various literature on the absence of parental influence in Disney Film, one cannot but help make interesting connections to the role (or lack thereof) of parents in the works of Edward Gorey. 

Throughout his oeuvre, Gorey has presented parents from across the spectrum.  From adoring and attentive parents to deceased parents; from protective parents to neglectful and downright abusive parents.  Gorey’s best-known work The Gashlycrumb Tinies presents to readers parents of the absent and neglectful variety. 

Initially published in 1963, The Gashlycrumb Tinies is an abecedarian book detailing the demise of 26 children.  The children meet their ghastly ends in various ways, plummeting down stairs in immense, dimly lit estates, swallowing deadly items, drowning in lakes, choking on peaches, being devoured by bears and leeches.  Of all the myriad means of expiration one thing remains constant, their parents are not to be found.

The role of parents (or advocating and caring substitutes, e.g. grandparents or foster parents) is important in children’s psychological development.  In the development of Self and Other, the parental role is a grounding principle, a force that establishes order and stability in the world and in the burgeoning Self.  However, in The Gashlycrumb Tinies there are no ordering, nor protecting forces watching over these unfortunate children, grounding their experiences and development.  But, unlike Disney films, these neglected children do not grow to become heroes and heroines.  In the shady realms of Gorey the children of absent parents are quickly and horribly destroyed.  

The ordering principle of the parent that grounded (and continues to ground?) the developing Self, including the ethical and ontological stance towards both one’s own existence and the existence of the universe (the “out there”), is non-existent to these children. Yet, within the vacuum left by the relinquishment of the ordering principle of adults and parents a trace of a new system of order can be detected, namely the formal structure of the work itself.  The abecedarian configuration of the book functions as a surrogate ordering principle, standing in for the missing guardians. 

A is for Amy who fell down the stairs
B is for Basil assaulted by bears

The abecedarian structure is, of itself, an ordering system at the level of the individual, in this case the individual letter (which is, in the book, the individual child). But more than an ordering system of individualization, the abecedarian structure implies a universal order.  Employing a sort of ontological argument, it can be maintained that the nature of any given individual letter is constituted by –and embedded in– a larger concept of an alphabet.  For there to be an “M” there must be the conceptual field a prior to the “M” that it is rooted into, this being the concept of an alphabet.

In this way, the formal abecedarian structure of the work points at a metaphysics Gorey is exploring, which is encapsulated in the one adult shown in the work, namely the umbrellaed devil-like figure of Death, with all his Edwardian elegance and Victorian slenderness, which literally stands over, watchful, possessive of the children on the front cover of the book.

The ontological value of the universe of the Gashlycrumb Tinies is one in which order, the Logos, is death.   In this Gashlycrumb universe order, logic, reason, stability, the rational structure of the world are all death.  In this universe Death, with all its connotations of evil, establishes the universe (and, in a Spinozian outlook, is the world), smoothing out, with calculated, fastidious fingers, the wrinkles of chaos, achieving a sort of impeccably balanced entropic demise of possibility.  If Life is growth open to possibility, then Death is the resolution of possibility.

The poet e.e. cummings captures the dichotomy between a disordered, chaotic, and impassioned Life and a fussy, meticulous, schoolmarm-esque Death when he writes that

in spite of everything
which breathes and moves,since Doom
(with white longest hands
neatening each crease)
will smooth entirely our minds
-before leaving my room
i turn,and(stooping
through the morning)kiss
this pillow,dear
where our heads lived and were.

In the realm of  The Gashlycrumb Tinies, God, the giver of Life, traditionally conceived as the architect of the world, the bearer of order, the Logos, the Word, may be more appropriately aligned with the primordial formlessness, and thus, lifelessness, which in the Abrahamic traditions preceded the creation of the universe.  In this topsy-turvy universe, God is formlessness, chaos, while the Devil is the creator of order, Logos, the field in which Life takes root.  Such a statement, of course, hinges upon the connotation of Death, personified on the front cover of Gorey’s work as a sort Grim Reaper, as a moral evil, but such a connotation is perfectly consistent with Western concepts of the Reaper, in general and to Edward Gorey in particular, as Victor Kennedy's demonstrates in Mr. Kennedy's treatment of the Devil and Gorey's The Disrespectful Summons. 

What unfolds in this reading is a sort of Gnostic metaphysics, in which a distinction is made between a Supreme Being and a demiurge, a creator deity (personified as the “devil”), responsible for the creation of the material universe, and is opposed to the Supreme Being.  In Gnosticism the demiurge’s creation of the universe was a violation of the Supreme Will.  As such, order, materiality, the universe itself is understood to be a defective construction.  Gorey may be presenting to us a hyper-contamination of the Platonic Ideal Forms, a material universe whose very core, its fundamental essence, is constituted in evil and the violation of the Supreme Good.  Put simply, existence is evil

Edward Gorey presents readers the dark abyss into which we stare, transfixed at the horror of not only the nature of ultimate reality, but of our reaction to it: we smile and giggle at the morbid humor presented in the Gashlycrumb Tinies.  Are we horrible, degenerated people, who take joy in our depravity?  Are our smiles the intuitive understanding and acknowledgment of such a ghastly universe?  Or, are the naughty, twinkled giggles a relief valve for the psychological and existentially stress that accumulates inside of us as we travel through an absurd world (both in our real lives and in the pages of Gorey’s work)?

Many thinkers saw laughter (smiles and giggles) as just such a relief valve.  The American philosopher John Dewey understood laughter as relief of nervous energy caused by agitation to the nervous system, writing that laughter is “a phenomenon of the same general kind as the sigh of relief.”  Sigmund Freud too formulated psychological relief theories regarding the cause of laughter, especially at violent situations.  Freud saw laughter as a release of physic energy that would have functioned as a force of psychological repression.  Instead of repressing a sexual or hostile urge (which is why sex jokes and violence jokes are often funny), the energy is released in laughter.

However, others postulate an alternative to the relief theory of laughter.  These thinkers argue that laughter and giggles as caused by an incongruence in our experience.  This has come to be called the Incongruence Theory of laughter. When an experience violates our mental patterns and expectation, laughter is the result. This theory of laughter explains much with regard to jokes, which contain a set-up, the setting of expectation and the punchline, the violating of expectation.  The resulting incongruence makes us laugh, because we enjoy the incongruence, we enjoy the surprise of the incongruence.  Though it should be noted that if one does not enjoy the incongruence, the result may be fear, disgust, or anger.  Tracing this idea, the Danish philosopher Soren Kierkegaard notes how closely related comedy and tragedy are, writing that the “tragic and the comic are the same, in so far as both are based on contradiction; but the tragic is the suffering contradiction, the comical, the painless contradiction.”

Those who “get” the joke, who delight in the incongruence, these individuals stare into the abyss presented by Gorey and see that such darkness does not quite align with their understanding of the world.  Perhaps this is the saving grace of Gorey’s The Gashlycrumb Tinies. Readers come to the work with expectations that the world will be good to children, children will be guided, watched over, protected, and as Gorey’s work unfurls itself the incongruence of readers’ expectations to what is being experienced causes them to smile, to giggle, to find a (morbid) humor in the work.  This is a positive thing.  The darkness Gorey presents, the cruel joke, is funny because it’s not how readers really perceive the world.  In essence, the work, oddly, in its depraved and violent vulgarity, shows how optimistic we are.  The dark little secret giggles are giggles of hope.

The Gashlycrumb Tinies is a dark, intriguing book, which presses up against the very limits of vulgarity, revealing the most paralyzing fears of both children and parents alike.  Yet, it reflects back to readers not a depravity, rather a possibility: the possibility of seeing the world as virtuous.  More than that the work opens up a space to help the world become more so, as readers are allowed to flex their virtue and ethics into the realm Gorey creates; we want to protect these children, and by extension our children, our world.

The Gashlycrumb Tinies reflects back to readers an ethical and ordered world that is above all good. Not necessarily in a religious or moral sense, though it doesn’t excluded those possibilities, but good in the sense that the word contains people who want to do good, and become better human beings. The mirror is dark, but what is seen in the glass is light.     






Comments