Art, Murder, and Retribution in Edward Gorey's "The Blue Aspic"



I.

A crucial moment of Edward Gorey’s The Blue Aspic comes early in the form of murder.  The renowned opera singer Gertrudis Callosidad is poisoned by an “unknown admirer.” Panel two captures the exact moment as she struggles against the venom, clawing at her throat, frantic for air, the attack sadistically timed such that Ms. Callosidad is forced to watch herself, wide-eyed in terror, in an elegant tri-fold vanity mirror backstage, slowly die (the irony here is evident as the backstage expiration is the only death, in a story jammed pack with fatal misdeeds, that is actually witnessed by readers).  When finally she is dead readers are left with the paramount question: who killed Gertrudis Callosidad?

There are three possible answers:

1.       An unintroduced character
2.       Ortenzia Caviglia
3.       Jasper Ankle

The first option is trite and uninteresting and thus dismissible. The second is intriguing enough, for it entails a fair amount of Nietzschean Will raised to a diabolical level (and then some, with the extenuated killings of additional characters).  However, it does nothing to provide satisfactory motive for the inclusion of Jasper Ankle.  Did he just happened to be present at Ms. Caviglia’s debut and manically hitch his newly found homicidal (c.f. Ortenzia’s final adieu) obsessed wagon to the rising star of Ms. Caviglia?  It is possible; but trite.  A Jasper of this sort is one-dimensional, a stock character, leaving the reader unfulfilled.

It is then the third option that offers us intrigue, passion, fulfillment, and, finally, an answer. The third way too contains the Nietzschean Will in relation to a diabolical, fully-realized Ortenzia.  Further, the third way animates Jasper, for this third options holds a pathos of the ages: the devastation of the disposed lover, and thus the third way gives us a tragedy of ambition and love, round and dynamic in its psychological truth:

Jasper Ankle murdered Gertrudis Callosidad to advance the career of his wife, Ortenzia Caviglia.

An explication of each panel will suffice to demonstrate the truth of this claim. For a more expedient read, one may wish to simply skip to the concluding section below.

Panel One:

Jasper waits in the rain to purchase the cheapest ticket to see the opera Le Vengeance Posthume.  Here one finds a bit of Gorey-esque word play, for “Jasper” is Persian for “treasure holder,” as well it is the traditional name given to one of the Magi present at the birth of the Christ.  It will be seen that the “treasure” that Jasper holds is Ortenzia. Note, too, that Jasper is present at the “birth” of her career.

The title of the opera itself is also a bit of foreshadowing.  The posthumous revenge of Jasper will develop throughout the story reaching its fatal point at story’s end as Jasper returns from the “dead” (implied: dead to Ortenzia; symbolism: the asylum, which is artistically peopled with a wraith-like individual in Panel 23) to dispose of Ms. Caviglia.

Panel Two:

Gertrudis Callosidad eats from a box of poisoned candies, perishing.  Outside of what has already been mentioned regarding the expiration of Ms. Callosidad, one sees subtle thematic indications in the meaning of the opera diva’s name.  Gertrude, meaning strong spear, and Callosidad, meaning callus.  With the combination of the two meanings an effect is achieved, namely the classic trope of “out with the old, in with the new.”  The traditional power center, the strong spear, the artist’s authority, has developed a callus; it is blunt and yellowed and unfeeling; it has lost its vitality, its authenticity, its essence of new illuminations that is the core of art. As such it needs be revolted against by the up-n-coming, the wave of the next generation crashes upon the shore of tradition, delivering new truths, fresh insights.

Panel Three

Ortenzia Caviglia makes her debut in the place of the deceased Callosidad.  The term Caviglia is the Italian equivalent of Ankle, and it is here that we see the first meaningful connection between Ortenzia and Jasper, they have the same surname.  Two possibilities arise, brother and sister, or husband and wife. The latter will be demonstrated to be the case.

Panel Four

After her successful debut Ortenzia is treated to supper by Baron von Knochel, the head of the opera.  Knochel is German for Ankle (!).  The Baron is a symbolic surrogate for Ortenzia’s husband; she is attracted to him as a surrogate (though, later, even the symbolic husband, and any attraction to such, is not necessary as her ambitious drive leads her further from her humble origins).  And it is as a symbol of her husband, Jasper, that she has sex with the Baron, keeping her out all night.

Panel Five:

Jasper awaits the return of Ortenzia.  He has waited until dawn to celebrate his wife’s success.  He has prepared a small meal, all they can afford, and has placed two glasses and a bottle of wine on the formally laid table top.  Waiting for his wife, who is in the arms of another, he begins to despair.

Panel Six

It is late in the opera season and Ortenzia is a huge success. The elegantly dressed upper-crust of society bandies her name about like a rare coin.   Ms. Caviglia has performed in such pieces as Gil occhielli (“The buttonholes”), Lizzia Bordena (an opera based on Lizzie Borden, who was tried and acquitted for the murder-by-axe killing of her parents), and La reine des iguanes (“The queen of the iguanas” a possible dig at Ortenzia's new found position withing the reptilian upper-class). At this point in the narrative Ortenzia’s star has risen and in the dust is left Jasper.

Panel Seven

Jasper seated at a desk in a crowded, dingy little office, distracted from his menial employment of “writing labels” by the numerous clippings of his estranged lover.  He has obsessively collected newspaper clippings of Ortenzia’s performances, and just as obsessively reads them over and over and over again. Attesting to the disposing of Jasper on Ms. Caviglia’s part, this Panel demonstrates the isolation,  both visually, being walled off by the bricks in his window and the staunch boxes of either side of a clearly distraught  Jasper; and emotionally as Jasper gazes down at the clip in hand with a look of utter lamentation and wistfulness.

Panel Eight

We have, with Ambrogio Rigaglie (“immortal giblets”), the second death to occur in the narrative.  The cause of death is as mysterious as Ms. Callosidad’s.  Was Mr. Rigaglie a victim of happenstance? Or was it murder?  It isn’t until additional victims begin to pile up that the latter suggestion is seen as the more apt explanation.  So, then, who is the murder? The answer is obvious: an obsessed Jasper Ankle.  Displaying Raskolnikov-like sensibilities for art, beauty, integrity and truth, Jasper, with the disposing of Ms. Callosidad in Panel Two, has granted himself an abhorrent avenue of expression, for more and more victims accumulate until the climatic finale.  Jasper’s crimes demonstrate a tortured and confused psyche, for the method of his killings are bizarre (e.g. a rectal impaling; e.g. public displays, a show), as well the choice of victims displays both a grotesque jealousy (“Oh, beware, my lord, of jealousy! It is the green-eyed monster which doth mock the meat it feeds on”) and a delusional paternal urge to protect Ortenzia’s virginal integrity, both sexually and artistically, as he offs one by one the males closest to Ortenzia, as well as her most zealous competitors.

Panel Nine:

Months and months later, the opera season is over, a record company has managed to record and mix an audio recording of Ortenzia singing Vivi con una mira (“Living with a look”) from the opera Il Fiore sotto il piede (“The  flower underfoot”).  Jasper sits on the edge of a dark pool in an empty park, hungry, for he has gone three days without a midday meal in order to save the necessary money to purchase this recording. 

Jasper is now completely alone.  There is no hope of seeing his wife again.  She has moved on, her ascent is glorious, in comparison to Jasper’s obsessive homicidal despair. Is it here that the germ of the finale begins to gather in the dark recesses of Jasper’s tortured mind?

Panel Ten

During the break between the opera seasons, Ortenzia appears in a series of advertisements for Grudge’s Cucumber Soap.  The Caviglia Brand is popular enough that she strikes out into other fields beside the opera.  She begins to accumulate both admirers and money, becoming a self-made woman (with the help, of course, of a little murder, here and there).

The symbolism of Grudge Soap cannot go unheeded.  The soap is a metaphoric signal to Jasper to acknowledge his dismissal by Ortenzia, to deal with the cold, hard facts: his assistance with her career will not be acknowledge nor will any gratitude be laid upon his head by his now estranged wife. He is being instructed to wipe away any hard feelings, to clean the slate, and begin anew.  The naivety of Ms. Caviglia cannot be overstated, for it is her ignorance of Jasper’s psychology, that will lead her to an untimely (though justified?) end.  Are the spotlights of fame that dazzle the eyes of Caviglia bright enough to burn away past deeds?  Can she now not imagine the misery which her abandoned husband suffers through? Has she no understanding of humankind?  It must be that above the heads of mortals, in the realm of the gods, the clouds are thick.

Panel Eleven:

The start of the new opera season. One year from the murder of Gertrudis Callosidad.  Jasper once more stands in a freezing rain to purchase the cheapest ticket to the show.  On tap for the evening’s entertainment is Die Chinesisiche Brille (“The Chinese Glasses”).

Panel Twelve:

Ortenzia Caviglia has her greatest performance to date as Tsi-Nan-Fu.  Ortenzia is clearly in new world, a new existence.

Panel Thirteen:

Beneath a picture of a lonely woman gazing out at the full moon, Jasper lies, fully clothed, in bed.  He is sick, despondent, and unemployed.  As Ortenzia glides ever higher, Jasper spirals further and further into a personal hell of envy, poverty, and guilt.

Panel Fourteen:

A wealthy and eccentric Duke of Whaup (Whaup, is a variety of wading bird) masked and dressed in a full fur coat presents to Ortenzia, who is adorned in a visually luxuriant gown, the renowned Spoffish emeralds.  The ornate, rococo setting of Ortenzia’s abode is juxtaposed with Jasper’s hovel in the previous panel. Ortenzia’s coy, faux-demure expression reveals much about the change in Ortenzia. 

The Spoffish (a term meaning earnest in matters of no importance) emeralds symbolize the ostentatious emptiness of her new life; the vapid, well-rehearsed façade of aristocracy.   The growing distance between Ortenzia-as-artist and the mere mortals that experience Art, may, as previously mentioned, threaten the artistic integrity of Ortenzia, as it did with her predecessor, Ms. Callosidad.

Panel Fifteen:

Jasper is seated at his simple table amongst the scattered pages of the extensive letters he pens to his lost wife, who can’t be bothered to answer them.  Because of his unemployment he no longer has access to his dismal office, and thus his collection of newspaper clippings.  Night after night he scripts letters while listening over and over again to audio recordings of Ortenzia, sinking ever deeper into what may be, in his clouding mind, a real-life reenactment of le vegeance posthume.

Against the wall in Japer’s tiny room is his only source of food, the cheap, distasteful cereal Filboid Studge, which was the center piece of 19th-century British writer Saki’s short story of the same name, and tells the tale of an unloved breakfast (Filboid Studge) that is re-branded, becoming a success.  The parallels between the unassuming breakfast cereal and Ms. Caviglia are telling.

Panel Sixteen:

Jasper manages to sneak back stage at a production of Teodora strangling Ortenzia’s nearest rival.  The opera is based, more than likely, on the play Theodora by the French dramatist Victorien Sardou, which tells the story of the Empress Theodora, a poor girl elevated to the rank of Queen who later abandons her husband to begin an affair with another man.  She poisons her lover and herself to avoid being strangled to death by her husband upon his discover of the adulterous trespass.

Panel Seventeen:

Without a job and with little or no money Jasper is evicted from his tiny apartment.  In the process, the last connection he has to his lost wife, his phonograph, is ruined.

Panel Eighteen:

Ortenzia continues to rise to the top of the cultural world, modeling for the masterpiece by the famous artist Sergissopov.  The work is marveled at by the elite connoisseurs of the art world. The visual luxuriousness of Caviglia’s world is evident once again in the full furs and the sumptuous carpets and drapery.

Panel Nineteen:

Jasper is now homeless, wondering the streets, slowly growing lonelier and more depressed and, of course, more homicidally desperate.  His most prized possession, the recordings of his Ortenzia, are warped and ruined. The symbolism is heavy.

Panel Twenty:

Jasper kills again. Ortenzia’s romantic interest, the Duke of Whaup, is crushed to death beneath falling statuary during an interval at the production of Amable Tastu, which was the pen-name of Sabine Voiart a French woman writer of the 19th-century. The play, presumably, is about her, Sabine’s, life, and her efforts to raise money for her family by producing literary art under an alternate identity.

Panel Twenty-one:

As Ortenzia sings Tazza di cacao (“A cup of cocoa”) at a rehearsal for L’avvelenatrice di Glasgovia (“The Poisoner of Glasgow”) Jasper is caught hiding in the wings of the opera house and subsequently booted from the building.  This is the first glimpse Jasper has had of his estranged wife in months (since the season opened with the production of Die Chinesische Brille in panel eleven). One can imagine the effect on Jasper was profound. For it leads to his arrest in Panel Twenty-two. One may also speculate as to how often previously Jasper lurked in the wings.

Panel Twenty-two:

Jasper is arrested during the triple-wedding scene of the opera Elagabalo, which dramatized the life of the Roman Emperor of the same name, who was, it should be noted, involved in many sex scandals’ in his time.  The details of his arrest are mysterious, but the situation was deemed dire enough to interrupt the opera.

Panel Twenty-three:

After his arrest Jasper is admitted to an asylum with his recordings of Ortenzia.  He is visited by a ghost-like fellow inmate.  Jasper is pensive as he sits on the floor in the bare cell.

Panel Twenty-four:

It is, once again, the languid interval between opera seasons.  With her free time Ortenzia has found a new love interest, the wealthy Basil Zaribaydjian, who takes her on an extended cruise on his yacht.

Panel Twenty-five:

The barefoot Jasper escapes from the asylum.  However, during the escape he loses the last material tokens of Ortenzia.  He is insane, desperate, on the run from the law.  He has no money, no food, no future. He is a deranged man with absolutely nothing to lose.

Panel Twenty-six:

During a production of Gomiti di rammarico (“The Elbows of Regret”) Jasper lashes out again.  A possible motive for the killing of M.Gazogene, is simply to signal to Ortenzia that he, Jasper, has returned.  Or: the motive could be the removal of an additional rival to Ortenzia, namely Mme Pince-Oreille (“Ear Clamps”), for Gazogene acted as leader of her sycophantic group of admires, which presumably gave Pince-Oreille a bit of a rise in her career, to be sponsored, in a manner, by a wealthy patron of the arts. But why then not simply target the rival directly? 

The answer may be found in the name of M. Gazogene, which literally means gas producer. The means of killing the man, rectal impalement, is indicative of Jasper’s artistic sensibilities.  The gas-producing man, who is “full of hot air,” is empty to the truth of art.  Gazogene is a simpleton, a flattering, kowtowing shell whose very presence and celebration of Mme Pince-Oreille is a danger to art itself. 

In the killing of Gazogene, Jasper is making a statement both about the nature of art as well who deserves access to it.  This statement will be explored at greater length later.

It should also be noted that the playwright George Bernard Shaw, crafted a short play titled Passion, Poison, and Petrification: The Fatal Gazogene (c.f. Gorey’s The Fatal Lozenge).  In Shaw's dramatic work a husband attempts to stab his adulterous wife and poison her lover. The intriguing allusions throughout The Blue Aspic are wonderfully devious.

Panel Twenty-seven:

Somehow (presumably panhandling) Jasper has scrounged enough money for a cheap ticket to the premier of Ortenzia’s newest work, Nera Agnese di Dunbar.  He waits in line outside the opera house in the middle of a blizzard to purchase the ticket. He is at wit’s end.   

Panel Twenty-eight:

During the singing of the aria Ah, paese dei bovini hispidid! (“The Land of Hospitable Cows!) Ortenzia has a premonition. 

Panel Twenty-nine:

Leaving the opera house with her most recent lover, the Maharajah of Eschnapur, a visually cocooned Ortenzia is stabbed to death by a crazed Jasper.

Panel Thirty:

Yelling out “J’ai trouve Hortense!” Jasper stabs himself, falling dead atop the lifeless Ortenzia.  The two are reunite in death.  The exasperation (of guilt, of longing, of poverty, of sanity, etc.) of Jasper and his dealing with the heights Ortenzia has soared to, leaving him far, far below, ends in a final lashing out, a final settlement, a final reclamation of both of their former idyllic selves.  A murder-suicide that brings a reclamation of the halcyon days of Bohemian delight.

II.

It is now, after a rather extenuated explication, evident that the original thesis is correct:  Jasper Ankle murdered Gertrudis Callosidad to advance the career of his wife, Ortenzia Caviglia.

Ortenzia either originally targeted Jasper Ankle for his love of art combined with his inherent susceptibility, or she, at some point in their relationship, realized that Jasper would make an excellent pawn in her game. However it occurred, it is evident that at the time of Callosidad’s killing Ortenzia did not love Jasper, for she was so easily able to cast him aside in her rapid ascent into the upper echelons of the art world.

Ortenzia married Jasper, taking his last name, yet, to give herself a certain flair in the flamboyant culture of opera (and possibly to keep herself psychologically distant from a man she does not respect) she went with the Italian of her new surname, Caviglia.

Well acquainted with the devilish intrigues of operatic narratives (as evidenced in the various operas of The Blue Aspic)[1], Ortenzia, and eventually Jasper, after some amount of cajoling, fixate upon the idea of poisoned candies given to the reigning diva of the opera world under which Ortenzia has managed to inveigle herself as understudy.  Jasper delivers the candies; the devil’s work is done.
The rest of the world assumed it was a lucky break for Ms. Caviglia, but the truth: it was murder most foul.

After the murder, and her extraordinary debut, Ortenzia quickly disentangled herself from Jasper, who is still in love.   Ortenzia’s star rises quickly, while Jasper, as has been demonstrated, sinks into a pit of despair.

It would have been a perfect crime, but for one thing:  Ortenzia’s error in underestimating the true depths of Jasper’s violent tendencies. The pawn grew more and more bold. Little did Ortenzia realize the capability of Jasper, as he continued to murder, fanatically devoting his being to the promotion and protection of his wife, who wanted nothing do with him.  How frantic Ortenzia must have grown as those around her were murdered one by one.  In a dangerous irony her operatic birth, La Vegeance Posthume, comes to life as her discarded husband, like a ghost, returned to haunt her, points his guilt ridden finger at the illicit mechanisms of her artistic rise.     

The guilt of both Jasper and Ortenzia increases, breeding ever more caliginous movement forward, filling their souls.  Ortenzia buries the guilt in her various affairs and commercial and artistic diversions, while Jasper is reduced to a homeless vagabond obsessed with the purity of art.  And in a final violent act of passion and retribution Jasper murders his wife, screaming out J’ai trouve Hortense (translated: “I found Ortenzia!”), as he reunites once again with his wife in death, protecting her, eternally, from the hollow trappings of her own success and the foulness which the pursuit of it cultivated in her once pure soul.  O, Jasper, the naivety of your purity.  O, Ortenzia the audacity to claim the heavens.




[1] In much the same way that Jorge Luis Borge’s character, James Alexander Nolan was familiar with the intrigues of Shakespeare and other pieces of classical literature in staging the assassination of the traitor Fergus Kilpatrick in the short story Theme of the Traitor and the Hero.

Comments

  1. What a fantastic read!
    C/would you tell me why it is called The Blue Aspic?

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment