Nietzsche's Overcoming in Edward Gorey's "The Eleventh Episode"


What follows is a brief, possible exposition of events in Edward Gorey’s The Eleventh Episode. A female protagonist hears a scream from outside.  While investigating the source of the scream, she accidentally falls down a well.  As she plummets downward she herself screams until landing in a heap of mud at the bottom of the well.  Apparently, due either to a head injury or the mere shock of such such an unusual turn of events, she forgets everything that has led to this moment.  At the bottom of the well she discovers a tunnel into an underground world, where she is assaulted by a rouge bicyclist. She defends herself against her assaulter, then flees to a far off land and takes up abode in a simple house. 

To give away a little of where this exposition is going, it can be seen that the house she eventually take possession of is actually the original house in which the story begins, which is made evident by panels 1, 8, 13, and 14, which reveal the same visual design.  The woman has merely forgotten, due to shock or head injury that she lived there. Yet, even in the fog of forgetfulness, she is still drawn to the place.

She paints, she plants a garden, a beast eats the dancing mice, a man informs her a cup will arrive in the mail. She waits weeks, yet nothing arrives.  She concludes she was distracted from her life by and resolves to cease her waiting about for the delinquent cup.  Standing, she walks to the window to close the curtain. Once there she hears a scream, her scream, from a former self, plummeting down the well, which she herself plummeted down earlier, though she does not recall her former state. She, of course. investigates and her present self falls down the well, and on and on….

This has happened already eleven times (The Eleventh Episode) and it can be supposed that it will happen again and again, in an eternal loop of time, reminiscent of the 1993 Harold Ramus film Groundhog Day, in which a man is forced to relive the same day countless times.

However, before Groundhog Day there was Friedrich Nietzsche, and his “most burdensome thought,” as a fellow German Philosopher Martin Heidegger called it, namely the question of the eternal return, as first articulated in Nietzsche’s Die fröhliche Wissenschaft (“The Joyful Science”):

       What, if some day or night a demon were to steal after you into your loneliest loneliness and say to you: 'This life as you now live it and have lived it, you will have to live once more and  innumerable times more' ... Would you not throw yourself down and gnash your teeth and curse the demon who spoke thus? Or have you once experienced a tremendous moment when you would have answered him: 'You are a god and never have I heard anything more divine.

Simply stated, the question asked, if you were to re-live your life, with its triumphs, disappointments, loves, and hates, over and over again for eternity, would that be to you Heaven or Hell?

The question of eternal return was a sort of litmus test for Nietzsche as to the value of one’s existence, and it is the test which the female protagonist of Edward Gorey’s The Eleventh Episode is faced with.  Is it a test she passes? Faced with the eternal return of existence is her life a success? Is it Heaven, or is it Hell?

Five years after the publication of The Joyful Science, Nietzsche’s Zur Genealogie der Moral (“On the Genealogy of Morals”) was published in which the German thinker sketches the parameters of his concept of the good life, that is, an existence worth living, an existence that would pass the test of the eternal return.  To live an existence that revels in the eternal return one needs a spirit “strengthened by wars and victories, for whom conquering, adventure, danger, pain have become a need; for this one would need acclimatization to sharp high air, to wintry journeys, to ice and mountain ranges.”  (I am put in mind here of Wallace Stevens’ poem The Snowman:

 …the listener, who listens in the snow,
And, nothing himself, beholds
Nothing that is not there and the nothing that is.

The being that possesses such a spirit Nietzsche called the Übermensch, a creator of new values, the Übermensch conquers the nihilism the eternal return produces in weaker spirits. The Übermensch does not celebrate the mediocrity of the masses, the Übermensch rises above the herd, living an existence alone, apart from the swarming flies of social sycophancy.  Such a person lives an iron-willed existence of creativity and solitude and struggle.

To return to the question at hand: has the female protagonist of The Eleventh Episode lived an existence which exults in the eternal return?

There is evidence for both sides.  She is curious and adventurous, evident in her investigation of the scream and later exploration of the subterranean world she falls into.  She takes decisive and violent action against the attacking bicyclist.  She journeys to remote places (though, of course, the remote place is actually her forgotten home land).  She produces Art, and forges with her bare hands the garden which allows the creative space for the dancing crepuscular creatures.  What’s more all of these activities are done in a stoic solitude worthy of the strength of the Übermensch.

However, at the end of the tale, the protagonist does something very un-Übermensch-like.  A mysterious motorist arrives, whose arrival was foreshadowed by the ominous appearance of the “monstrous beast” that devours the dancing mice.  This motorist, with his weapon-like vehicle, informs her of a cup she must wait for. She believes his fabrication that the cup will soon arrive, and consequently retreats into a passivity of waiting, hands folded, polite and demure, life wasting away.    
It is this mediocre waiting that causes her to now lament, when once she celebrated, that life is “distracting and uncertain,” and then to nihilistically wish to extinguish life with the symbolic gesture of closing the curtain.

However, at the most vital moment of her existence, her adventurousness is resurrected as the eternal return activates and she once more hears the scream in the process of drawing her curtain down.  And thus, in the final moment, before her metaphoric suicide, she re-engages her existence through a daring curiosity and struggles, creatively on, her moment of weakness vanquished.

It's protagonist succeeds, but Gorey's The Eleventh Episode illustrates the cruel seductiveness of simply accepting a life defined by someone else’s manipulation (the lie of the grail delivered by the mysterious rocketed-car man), rather than the struggle to create an authentic Being.  The tale's warning about the nihilism of modern life with is random violence, rampant militarism, insane leaders, demonstrates that overcoming the bleakness, conquering the pettiness and frustration, is both difficult and lonely.  The work is hard, and constant, but the alternative to this existential work is nothingness, becoming food for "monstrous beast" that devours the small and the weak. 

Comments