Notes on Distance and Unconsciousness in Walter Benjamin's "The Lucky Hand"


Walter Benjamin's short story, The Luck Hand, is a marvel of a work.  What follows here are a scattering of ideas, organized by topic as an outline:

Issues of Distance and Desire:

·         The group of men are “sitting in cozy seclusion form the world,” as the peer out at a “semaphore” which is a communication tool used to relay messages (visually) over a great distance.
o   The “seclusion” seems to indicate a “distance” from the world, a distance that introduces a “coziness” a sated feeling, a Desireless Feeling of Distant Detachment.
o   They are ‘secluded’ from the world: separation, but not alienation.
§  The Eye
·         The Distance and Nearness is operated via the Eye, more specifically the Glance or the Gaze
·         The eye is the organ of “perceptional space,” the organ that delimits and synchronized the distance and the near.
·         The story of Dal Pozzo: she is disengaged, she has no Desire to win, she has no Desire, no Lack, and thus she wins, for to lose, would produce a Lack (the want of winning, the want of money)
o   Ontological stance controls or creates the metaphysical realm (see below)
o   I.e.  my being mandates how the universe will exist.

Distance is the Unconscious | Nearness is Conscious:
·         Dal Pozzo Sleeps:  She becomes unconscious when she plays, and thus wins.  Connects with the discussion of unconsciousness later in the story.  What is the conscious and what is unconscious?
·         Space (and Time) are crafted by the mind, as the mind crafts Self in Space and Time (Kant).  
o   Thus, “Distance” and “Closeness” are not spatial-concepts, rather than psychological and philosophical concepts.  
o   And thus the eye seeing/perceiving the constant fluctuation between Distance and Closeness, the vacillation between Ground and Figure (Self and Other?), is the mind’s (self?) fluctuation between an seamless back-n-forth of Conscious and Unconscious, between Desire and Non-, between Lack and Wholeness, between Being and Not..
o   This is an accelerated Hyper-Dialect, in which there can be no Thesis and Antithesis (thus no “progression”; no Time), for the fluctuation is dependent upon the Fluxed (the Ground and Figure combined) and the Flux (the movement of the mind within the Fluxed).  
§  Such there is no Synthesis.  
o   A dialectal structure that eliminates itself constantly (the components of the dialectal are present but so hyper they constantly vanish into the other components), and is constantly already eliminated, an /a prior/ eliminated-experience (the backside of Badiou’s “event,” which happens, not rarely, but continuously, or more accurately can’t ever happen, since it has already happen: it has already has-happened continuously). 
o   William James: “The Principles of Psychology” :
§  “Let anyone try, I will not say to arrest, but to notice or attend to, the present moment of time. One of the most baffling experiences occurs. Where is it, this present? It has melted in our grasp, fled ere we could touch it, gone in the instant of becoming.”
§  We experience Time as a Now, but a Now-that-has-already-been.
o   If Deleuze posits the idea that thinking is a violent confrontation with reality, an involuntary rupture of established categories, because thinking isn’t easy, it doesn’t automatically or inherently have the ability to grasp truth…By setting aside the assumption that thinking has a innate ability to recognize the truth, Deleuze says, we attain a "thought without image’ (where image is “truth,” i.e. thinking that doesn’t automatically have “truth” as its referent, or truth as even a possible outcome)
§  “Thought without image” may be realized in that the “image” is already has-happened inside every moment, i.e. inside the Time the mind creates, as well as inside the Space.
§  According to Deleuze a philosophical concept "posits itself and its object at the same time as it is created," yet it may be more that the philosophical concept posits itself and its objects at the same time it has already has-happened, i.e. the Dialectical Structure (e.g. Ground/Figure) that creates the concept and object is only a trace.
·         Combo of James and Deleuze
§  (Does the unconscious dwell in the image before the image has already has-happened?)
o   There is nothing in the present moment. The “present moment” is only an already has-happened.  It is only a Lack, a Desire.  Consciousness is Lack, is Desire.  (But, there is constant, instantaneous “movement” between UNC and C)
o   The consciousness is nothing (Satre);
o   Unconscious is EVERYthing, it is the TOTAL KNOWLEDGE that allows even the possibility to know.  But no “knowledge” can be known as a separate distinction (you can’t just know the Ground and not the Figure). Knowledge is Knowledge of EVERYthing.  But it is always separated from the Consciousness.  Rather separated by the Flux between Unconscious and Conscious.  
o   By generating (or being) Desire, i.e. consciousness, we can create “pull” a temporal gravity to move the Unconscious INTO consciousness, to move knowledge to where it is not.  
o   But we have to continually create Desire for once we pull the Unconscious into the Conscious, the Unconscious becomes an imperial force, it KNOWLEDGE-fies the Conscious, that is, it turns the Conscious into the Unconscious, such that Consciousness must continually create Desire, Lack, no-Knowledge or else it will immediately become Unconscious.
§  Unconscious animals are, to be simple about, soon to be dead animals
·         Unless, of course, the Unconscious animals has servants like Dal Pozzo
o   Time’s enactment on the body (i.e. Aging), is the Will of the Conscious to do this (Will? What is Will?), to keep generating Desire, Lack, it is the will slacking, growing tired.
§  Eventually the Ultimate Unconscious, the Ultimate TOTAL KNOWLEDGE, Death, will occur, in which there are no separate parts, no ground/figure, no self/other, no life/death.  
o   Time is created by the Desire, the emptiness of Consciousness as it “pulls” the Unconscious into it, this pull is experienced fundamentally as “Time.”
§  Time is the trace of the hyper-Dialect destroying itself; Time is the sensation of this destruction, how we experience this destruction; Time is the already has-happened of the elimination of the Hyper Dialect. (See William James quote).
·         Too, the feel of “desire” the emptiness, the incompleteness is felt as a component of the feeling of Time, especially of “Time passing” and the melancholy it results in.
·         Thus: Dal Pozzo, slips into Unconsciousness (Distance), the Total Knowledge, she awakens into Consciousness (nearness), and the trace of the knowledge remains for the briefest of moments (fading in its intensity every instant as further and further destruction occurs), in which she plays (and wins) before falling back into Unconsciousness.

The Nearness of the Woman on the Bench:
·         It is important that the person on the bench is a woman.
·         The actual impossibility of seeing that which is so very close, of knowing that which is so very close, is key to the generating of Desire.  For what is Near, is attracted by a gravity-two to the Unconscious All, which it, that which is near, that which is Nothing, is a part of.  The object in space (space being a psychological projection) is near,
o   Gravity-one is the “gravity” of the Pull of the Unconscious into Consciousness because of the Lack, the hole that consciousness is. 
o   Gravity-two is a addendum gravity pulls the consciousness towards unconsciousness (?) or is the “hole” itself that draws the unconscious (?)
o   The Unconscious All may be the sum total of the language (a Lacanan unconscious) , the net of signifiers, that form the tapestry of knowledge (and the rules of how to weave the tapestry).
·         Slavoj Zizek (Courtly Love, Or, Woman as a Thing):
o   “…Lacan accentuates the motif of anamorphosis…the Object can be perceived only when it is viewed from the side, in a partial, distorted form, as its own shadow –if we cast a direct glance at it we see nothing, a mere void.  In a homologous way, we could speak of temporal anamorphosis: the Object is attainable only by way or an incessant postponement, as its absent point of reference.  The Object, therefore, is literally something that is created –whose place is encircled –through a network of detours, approximations and near-misses.  It is here that sublimation sets in –sublimation in the Lacanan sense of the elevation of an object into the dignity of the Thing: ‘sublimation’ occurs when an object, part of everyday reality, finds itself at the place of the impossible Thing.  Herein resides the function of the artificial obstacles that suddenly hinder our access to some ordinary object: they elevate the object into a stand-in for the Thing.”
·         (To continue the thought of Courtly Love and connect it to the Lady on the Bench) In this case the anamorphosis is achieved by the distortion of form caused by nearness.  The woman situates herself near the Lacanan Real. In a manner of speaking she sets herself up between the Real and the Subject of the male, such that, as Zizek continues in his essay, she becomes the Lacanan Mirror, that which reflects back, as a Whole, the fractured and segmented structure of the Male, becoming, by becoming Whole, the Imaginary (the imaginary whole); the Lady situates herself as the power of wholeness (c.f. “mother nature”) as well the power to grant wholeness (which then she exploits this power at times in very sadistic ways as the Courtly Lady “subjects him [the knight] to senseless, outrageous, impossible, arbitrary, capricious ordeals.” One poem from the middle ages details the fact that the Lady commands a knight to lick her ass, and he’s worried of the smell and that she might urinate on him).
o   C.f. Lousie from Story of an Hour as Lady of Courtly Love.
o   The concept of Feminine Guilt as the existential residue of this sort of absolute power that has been hidden in popular contemporary ideological approaches to the past.
o   Rather, Feminine Guilt is the guilt that power is hoarded in such a way that reduce the male to a nothing and a noThing.  Near the end of his essay Zezik writes that there is a possible way to progress beyond this Power hierarchy and achieve a sort of equality:
§  “After this painful revelation [of the Lady and power], the relationship between the two is reversed . . . It is only at this point that true love emerges, love as a metaphor in the precise Lacanian sense: we witness the sublime moment when eromenos (the loved one) changes into erastes (the loving one) by stretching out her hand and ‘returning love’. This moment designates the ‘miracle’ of love, the moment of the ‘answer of the Real’; . . .”
o   However, the hand is not stretched out by the Lady, it is kept withdrawn and entrenched in reconstituted ideologies that manifest themselves differently, but have beneath the surface identical power structures as that of the Lady of Courtly Love.
·         Because the Lady on the bench has situated herself to be at such nearness to the Real, and the symbolic nearness of being near the man on the bench, a direct glance at her, at the Real, at True Power, is impossible, for her proximity to the real and the claim of power it offer results in her power grab (turning herself into the Mirror), to produce an Imaginary Male Subject. She turns herself into a “black hole” that draws men into her, into her mirror such that only through her, they can become Subjects and/or Self. 
·         Zizek writes:
o   “The place of the Lady-Thing is originally empty: she functions as a kind of ‘black hole’ around which the subject’s desire is structured. The space of desire is bent like space in the theory of relativity; the only way to reach the Object-Lady is indirectly, in a devious, meandering way—proceeding straight on ensures that we miss the target.”
·         But, she herself is not a “black hole” to herself, she only present herself as a “black hole’ to the male, so that he may structure his desire about her, near her, his desire of her, is his nearness to her; his desire of her, is the hole in himself caused by the mirror (which may at this point may be thought of as an actual image rather than mirror) she shows him.  The Lady in her nearness, creates the desire, the hole, the emptiness that the male must construct to even be conscious.  The male’s consciousness, the male’s emptying of himself, digging the hole that his Self is, is the purpose of the Lady in her absolute sadism and capriciousness and hunger for power.
§  The “black hole” is not a singularity is a construct of multiplicity.  There is no essential human to the Lady (no essentialist or “natural” sexuality of the Lady). The Lady is indefinable and open, decentered, non-phallic. The Lady is non-gendered (both the Lady’s hetero- and homo- draping entice the Male to dump his Real into her mirror).
§  As a multiplicity, it is Unconscious, it transcends desire. It does not Desire power (For the male Desires power) is IT power.
·         However, if Power is an extra-personal force the power may be only channeled by the Lady.

Unconscious/Conscious as Signifier and Signified:
·         The Mirror reflects wholeness but the whole is Imaginary, the whole becomes internalized as a whole, unified, self, i.e. a concept.  Thus, the “whole” (which Lacan situates as Freud’s ego, thus:) the Ego, is, in the language of Saussure, the signified, the concept, while the language used to access this Imaginary (a language of the other, thus alien to us), is the  Symbolic realm of Lacan, and of the realm of the signifier of Saussure. 
·         The Ego-as-Consciousness is the Signified, is the concept.  But, since Consciousness is empty, the concept is empty, the concept is an issue of the contours.  Whatever crowds the borders, the contours, is the conceptual.
o   Derrida: the centerless structure
·         This centerless structure is the black hole of Zizek, it is the hole in the visual field caused by the blind spot, or scotoma, because of the optic nerve, which is why the Eye (and its limitations) are important as being the organ of seeing distance and nearness.

The Lucky Hand:
·         The hand is disembodied; it is the hand that is lucky.  The hand, by being disembodied, becomes an object at a distance, the hand is at a distance from the self, the signified, the empty center, the empty concept.  The hand, at a distance becomes unconscious, thus, desireless, thus it wins (w/r/t success in gambling).  It is the hand, that is Desireless, that wins, not the desirous, empty consciousness.
·         Alice and the distancing of the body (Alice in Wonderland, Chapter 2):
o   “'now I'm opening out like the largest telescope that ever was! Good-bye, feet!' (for when she looked down at her feet, they seemed to be almost out of sight, they were getting so far off). 'Oh, my poor little feet, I wonder who will put on your shoes and stockings for you now, dears? I'm sure I shan't be able! I shall be a great deal too far off to trouble myself about you: you must manage the best way you can; —but I must be kind to them,' thought Alice, 'or perhaps they won't walk the way I want to go! Let me see: I'll give them a new pair of boots every Christmas.'

And she went on planning to herself how she would manage it. 'They must go by the carrier,' she thought; 'and how funny it'll seem, sending presents to one's own feet! And how odd the directions will look!

·         Within the World of Alice, her body, is not her body, it is a body, an object at a distance, and thus she has no control over it, no conscious control, it is unconscious w/r/t her relation of it.

Comments