Desire, Ethics, and Emptiness: a quick note on Murakami's "Kafka on the Shore"


In Murakami’s novel Kafka on the Shore we read 15 year-old Kafka’s thoughts on destiny:

The world is a huge space, but the space that will take you in -- and it doesn't have to be very big -- is nowhere to be found. You seek a voice, but what do you get? Silence. You look for silence, but guess what? All you hear over and over is the voice of this omen. And sometimes this prophetic voice pushes a secret switch hidden deep inside your brain.

Throughout the novel the themes of Fathers are explored, Kafka has a desire (or expectation) for a relationship with his Father.  However, when Kafka moves toward the relationship, towards the “space” where the relationship “ought” (which this space then is an “ethical” space that “ought” to be there) to be (or when he creates the space for the relationship) there is “nothing” there, there is only a “silence.”

In this space-of-silence (space-of-nothing [no-thing]) Kafka desires and has expectation for a presence, a “thing,” a “voice”, the voice of the Father, but hears only Silence, since his own Father is forever absent.  To fulfil his desire he then must generate his own “something” to fill the space as it “ought” to be filled. Thus, he creates his own Voice, which is the figure of Crow (the “death-Father” or rather, the Father returned from Death).  

But, this is a sort of entrapment in the space that has now become ONLY you (a solipsism).  The space was entered/created as a communicative space, a space of components, discourse, and multiplicities, but such a space with Kafka’s father is “nothing,” no-space, silence (a space that is “nowhere to be found.”).  But, the space “ought” (an “ought” rooted in desire) to be a communicative space, Kafka understands, and consequently he creates a voice to communicate with (Crow) thus, he defiles the original space and dominates it (an imperialism of sorts), he turns the space of and for “two,” into a space of and for “one.” 

But, this “solipsistic space” still retains the façade of the communicate space-of-two (Kafka literally hears and sees Crow as “another” identity in the space).  This façade is retained by the necessary split of Kafka into two, into fragments.

This fragmentation of self, may be a necessary result of all “oughts” regarding the world.  That is, expectations in general may always result or be rooted in the necessary fragmentation of self.  When a self levels expectations (“oughts”) at Reality a fragmented self is the result, for it detaches a self from reality and thrust this alienated self into a hypothetical realty (the reality envisioned in an “ought”). 

This fragmentation of self, may be a necessary result of all “oughts” (i.e. ethics) regarding the world.  Ethics split the individual into multiplicities, thus the ever enlarging of Murakami’s “ought space” culminating in 1Q84’s incredibly massive “other world” (i.e. “other space”) space. 
A movement throughout Kafka on the Shore may be the reclamation of this desired communicative space as a communicative space. The reclamation of the world, of the Other as existing in the world.  As the novel progresses, this “solipsistic space” is opened out, to once again include others, and an entire geography, though only a slice of geography, a valley village, and not, yet, the world sized healing space of 1Q84.

Comments