They're both gone to the town. Just look along the road, and tell me if you can see either of them.'
'I see nobody on the road,' said Alice.
'I only wish I had such eyes,' the King remarked in a fretful tone. 'To be able to see Nobody! And at the distance too! Why, it's as much as I can do to see real people, by this light!'
We look down the open road that entices our sight and we see nothing, a gap, a space. A space. An invisible architecture, a pure room, inside which the real, the authentic dwells. We cannot know what we see when we see nothing. The Ethic is then, too, a blindspot in our self-knowing. We ought to, but we know not what it is we ought. We. Know. Not.
Knowledge then is a gap, like the Ethic. Knowledge is like the Eye that sees, and by seeing denies. The red car swallows every wavelength of light but red. The red is not present in the car, red is a gap, a missing space in the wavelengths of light, and it is that missing space, that “hole” that we discover, that we see, that we know. Knowledge denes the world in a like manner. Knowledge pulls one wavelength out, and creates a “hole” in the world. Thus, there is always a “hole” in knowledge, in the Rhetoric of knowledge, in the systems of rhetorical knowledge that constitutes an Ideology. And Ideology denies the totality of the world, it pulls out the wavelengths of the world, the very thread of the real, and then weaves together a seamless curtain that hides the world, that divides the world into noumenal and phenomenal, known and unknown, everything and nothing, consciousness and un, ground and figure. Knowledge creates the binary, which are two locales on a spectrum, while it denies the spectrum, hides us from it.
Thus, Knowledge dominates and oppresses the world, segregating it into divisible individuation (the binary ends), which is an abstraction of the world, a violence to the authentic thing.
Thus, my question, finally, I suppose, which now seems a bit simple, then: Do we have a Right to knowledge? Do we have the Right to enact the violence of oppression and segregation and abstraction on (and of) the world so that we may possess knowledge?
Or another way: Does Genly have the Right to know and to report his findings of Knowledge? Does he have a Right to stereotype? To call the planet Winter? To see the inhabitants of Gethen through his lens of Knowing? Le Guin, in Chapter 7 (the “sex” chapter), seems to propose the thought experiment of the elimination of the ability to abstract unto knowing, via a hyper-enlargement of the categories of abstraction. Or is she merely suggesting changing the binary? Changing the mode of violence to the world? And what may the Zen-like practitioners of Handdara have to say about the violence of Knowledge? Is it an innate result of our species’ hard-wired brain structure, or is it a learned violence?

Comments
Post a Comment