One of the more interesting questions that emerges from Twelfth Night is the reason of Orsino arrival at Olivia’s estate at the beginning of Act 5, an action he has never undertaken in his entire courting of her. While some productions of the play have ignored this question, others have attempted an answer. For example, Trevor Nunn’s 1996 cinematic production of the play inserts a quick line from one of the arresting officers (of Antonio) instructing a fellow officer to notify the Duke of the apprehension of Antonio at Olivia’s, thus lending a reason to Orsino’s visit.
However, this notification of Antonio’s arrest does not exist in the play’s original text. As such, Nunn’s answer to the question is no answer at all, leaving unresolved the issue still.
So, why does Orsino travel to Olivia’s estate? One possibility is rooted in convergence of jealousl, namely, that Orsino arrived at Olivia’s with the intention of murdering her.
Prior to his reappearance in Act 5, the last time we saw Orsino was Act 2, Scene 4, where he is found him obsessing on the suffering caused, according to the egocentric Orsino, by Olivia’s continual rejection of him. His psychological fixation on his suffering as well Olivia herself has obscured and banished all other concerns from his life (similar to Othello’s farewell occupation scene) telling Cesario that
…lovers are,
unstaid and skittish in all motions else
save in the constant image of the creature
that is beloved.
Orsino’s ennui-stricken desperation has latched upon Olivia as a sort of fetish object, and he regresses deeper and deeper into the maniacal, hyper-focus on his self-absorbed suffering, blotting out his whole life save his obsession with Olivia.
Later in this same scene we hear Feste sing “Come Away Death,” a tune narrating the plight of a young lover “slain” by a “cruel, fair maid.” This same terminology of cruelness is reprised a few lines later when Orsino demands Cesario once more plead Orsino’s case to Olivia, who an embittered Orsino now mocks as a “sovereign cruelty.” Orsino is well on his way positioning himself as victim, as Othello does in his play, yet more, we sense in Orsino a masochistic, adoration of his contrived victimhood.
Immediately after this self-victimization melodrama is played out, Cesario attempts to explode Orsino’s masochism, by plainly, and quite vehemently, informing Orsino that Olivia cannot love him:
Viola: But if she cannot love you, sir-
Orsino: I cannot be so answered.
Viola: Sooth, but you must.
And it is this dram of information that Orsino is left to ruminate over as Cesario exits towards Olivia’s at scene’s end.
And ruminate Orsino does, for by the time we arrive at Act 5 Orsino has figured out that Olivia is in love, not with himself, but rather with Cesario:
And that I partly know the instrument
That screws me from my true place in your favour,
Live you the marble-breasted tyrant still;
But this your minion, whom I know you love.
In light of this fact, most productions inadequately represent, emotionally, Orsino’s arrival at Olivia’s. Too often he is portrayed from anywhere between giddy (e.g. Trevor Nunn) and his already familiar love sickness. However, when he arrives at Olivia his mood is foul, and is quite disturbed, for he arrives full of disdain at Olivia. As such, his lines in Act 5, up to, or course, the Revelation, should be articulated with a cruel bitterness and irony (“Here comes the Countess. Now Heaven walks on earth-), for he has already discovered, at least to his satisfaction, why Olivia does not love him.
Too, most productions treat the stage directions for the entrance of Orsino (“Enter Orsino, Viola, Curio, and Lords”) a bit too delicately. The heaviest (read: most provocative) of entrances would be Orsino, deranged in appearance, skittishly entering stage left, and franticly hiding on stage, as his court enters opposite stage, desperately looking for Orsino, who over the past day (since Act 2, Scene 4) has become increasingly bitter and demonstrative in his anger at Olivia and, it is probable to thinking, Cesario, and he, Orsino, has only this morning disappeared from court, leaving his entourage to “e’er since pursue” him.
In this reading, Orsino’s rage is somewhat checked and sublimated at the sight of Antonio’s capture, for here is a fellow deserving of the Duke’s rage, and offered up to the righteousness of the State’s punishment. Antonio’s plight is dangerous, for the growing sadism of the Duke can now transfer his want of bodily destruction away from Olivia to Antonio, in a legally legitimate manner. Once Orsino regains his composure, Olivia enters, and the controlled, though still rabid, bitterness is permitted voice as Orsino greets Olivia in his bleakly, ironic way (“Heaven walks on earth”).
This bitter irony is quickly increased to near homicidal jealousy once again as Olivia proceeds to ignore the Duke (she address Cesario),then, once more, answering bitterness for bitterness, she dismisses the Dukes amorous advances. This is too much for the Duke, who launches into a vitriol-lace diatribe threatening to murder both Olivia and Cesario:
Why should I not, had I the heart to do it,
Like to the Egyptian thief at point of death,
Kill what I love?--a savage jealousy
That sometimes savours nobly. But hear me this:
Since you to nonregardance cast my faith,
And that I partly know the instrument
That screws me from my true place in your favour,
Live you the marble-breasted tyrant still;
But this your minion, whom I know you love,
And whom, by heaven I swear, I tender dearly,
Him will I tear out of that cruel eye,
Where he sits crowned in his master's spite.
Come, boy, with me; my thoughts are ripe in mischief:
I'll sacrifice the lamb that I do love,
To spite a raven's heart within a dove.
The emotional (and self constructed ) gamut that Orsino has run in less than a day is incredible, moving from a narcissistic masochism to a vile, murderous sadism, whose inevitable fruit, the slaughtering of Cesario, is only arrested by the Revelation.
However, immediately before Sebastian enters, ushering in the Revelation, a violent commotion is unleashed as Andrew and Sir Toby storm into the scene, surrogate victims of Orsion’s urge and vision of violence towards Olivia. The two knights have been thrashed by Sebastian, and their gory thrashing is on the threshold of acting as blood-in-the-water for the enraged Orsino who has just learned that Cesario has betrayed his trust and married Olivia. One can imagine the murderous rage seething within Orsino’s heart moving to manifest itself in vicious murder. But, suddenly Sebastian appears on the stage, and the Revelation occurs, resulting in the inevitable endings of Elizabethan comedy: marriage. But, the glint of its twin play, Othello, cannot be so easily repressed by Twelfth Night’s paired weddings. Malvolio, who will morph into the diabolical Iago some years later, promises his vengeance, and vengeance he will have, for, as Iago, he will act as a conduit for the wrathful wraith of jealously in Orsino’s heart, conducting the darkness into the great Othello.

Comments
Post a Comment