Robert Frost and the Echo Chamber of Self

Robert Frost's Stopping by Woods on a Snowy Evening contains in its concluding couplet the most famous echo in American poetry, and miles to go before I sleep/and miles to go before I sleep. It is an echo of thought bouncing back from the edge of the woods, demonstrating a limit to the mind, the self, delineating the boundaries of solipsism.

The echo from the woods suggests an outer limit from which the thoughts of the speaker are reverberated back at him.  The Speaker here dwells within a more condensed, a more crowded (look at all those trees!) space than the mind of Whitman’s speaker situated in a “measureless oceans of space,” of his A Noiseless Patience Spider from a century before.  How, the times have changed between these two quintessential poets exploring the American mind.

The crowded modern world of Frost, exhausted of all the new, raw frontiers to discover, the frontiers of Whitman and the “measureless” spaces of the mind, sits domesticated and measured.  Nothing is left to discover, so let us fight it out to divide up what we have.  WWI is enters stage right.  The “ceaselessly musing” mind of Whitman, a century later, is not ceaselessly creating itself anew, it is ceaselessly talking to itself through its own echo in the dark, dead, overcrowded woods, through which it tramps, the owner of the woods, God, maybe even Whitman himself, is absent in the woods, assumed to be neutered now, tamed, domesticated in some nice, warm, cozy village home, stocked with a pantry of groceries and all the trappings of stunted authenticity.

In Frost’s vision the mind is reverberated back on itself, and instead of exploring, “venturing, throwing, seeking the spheres…” the mind withdraws on itself, echoes back to itself, is chained to itself, and like a shackled dog on the front lawn, spins in its tethered orbit, until the grass is dead, and the earth is covered in urine and shit. 

The mind locked in its box, an idiot telling tales and lies, (cf Wallace Stevens' Tea at the Palaz of Hoon), descending into fairy tells about the power of the imagination -what a load of Hoonian hogwash! In Woods the power of the imagination is a disease of egotism and irony.

The ironic detachment creeping into the American mind by the turn of the 20th century is seen in the difference between the contained, limited, and impotent feed-back loop of the Speaker of Woods, and the “measureless” metaphysical spaces of creativity and possibility of Spider’s Speaker.  For certainly Frost is a dark, contained scribe.  The editors of Contemporary Literary Criticism writing that "Frost's best work explores fundamental questions of existence, depicting with chilling starkness the loneliness of the individual in an indifferent universe,” and the critic T. K. Whipple focused on this bleakness in Frost's work, stating that "in much of his work, particularly in North of Boston, his harshest book, he emphasizes the dark background of life in rural New England, with its degeneration often sinking into total madness."

In the echo-chamber of Woods’ Speaker is created a sort of mediated experience, the sort of mediated experience Whitman notes makes his Speaker “tired and sick” in his When I Heard the Learn’d Astronomer, coaxing the Speaker to rise and glide outdoors (though of course the Speaker does wait until he has gained all the knowledge from the Astronomer “applause” is heard at the end of the lecture) back into the “measureless oceans of space.”  In Frost, the self itself becomes a mediated experience, the self itself cannot even exist as a raw, uncontrolled, unscripted Being, it must mediate itself as a self, it can only be mediation, it poses itself as an object to itself, and that ego-object mediates its own Being.  And while this split is hinted at in Whitman’s Spider (“And you O my soul…) in Whitman it is handled more as a literary trope than a real objectifying cleft.  

And I of course mention Wallace Stevens, the poetic insurance salesman, who plays an interesting role in the caged solipsism of the blunt, blue suited American mind, who daily, dallied forth in starched shirts, and tight ties on his walks to work composing fathomless depths of verse.   And these depths were a hardnosed attempt to deal with the condensing of the American mind (cf Alan Bloom), as the corpulent Stevens straddled the two men, Whitman, Frost, balanced above, precarious, one foot here, the other there.  For Steven’s character Hoon, as impotent, though not as fouly mooded, as Frost, Hoon who claims “I was the world in which I walked,” is just as trapped in the echo of self as the Speaker of Woods.  But, where Woods’ Speaker is foul and moody, and his enclosed world is dark and cold and full of death, Hoon’s self-created world is one of light, and joy, and creativity (and hippste beards).  This is the first pushback against the darkness of ironic detachment, the first attempt to reclaim the “measureless oceans of space.”  

The second attempt comes in the later poems of Stevens, where we see the possibility of an objective world where Being is situated, and the objective world is a realm of transcendence to Subjectivism  (especially an solipsist Subjectivism), for, as Harold Bloom writes, “the object marks the limits of solipsism.”  This limit however is not an impenetrable boundary, one which echoes back to us our selves, rather it is the liminal realm, a realm in which the self can not-be, or has the possibility, the danger, and exhilaration of not-being.  In Stevens’ latter poems the tense, exhilarated, dangerous Freedom of Whitman returns a possibility to the American mind that Frost’s Speaker is alienated. 

Comments