Tybalt’s Blind Eye: Shame and Secrets in Romeo and Juliet

Commentary of Tybalt’s culpability in the tragic outcome of Romeo and Juliet often focuses on his duel with Mercutio, which, of course, Mercutio began, thus thrusting the much of the responsibility onto Mercutio, whose death at the hands of Tybalt enrages Romeo, leading to Tybalt’s killing and Romeo’s banishment.   A closer inspection of the work’s construction, however, reveals that Tybalt’s culpability commences the night before this afternoon fight scene, and is rooted in Tybalt’s witnessing of Romeo and Juliet’s first kiss at the Capulet Ball.

During the Capulet Ball, Tybalt recognizes Romeo’s voice ("This, by his voice, should be a Montague-") when Romeo first spies Juliet and inquires her out.  Tybalt, enraged, plunges into the festive crowd to “strike him dead,” but is halted by Lord Capulet, who complements Romeo, ordering Tybalt to “let him alone.”  Capulet's command infuriates Tybalt, and a heated exchange takes place between the Lord and Tybalt.  Tybalt is ordered to shut up and bear his self-cultivated shame.  Lord Capulet then wonders out of the scene, and Tybalt tells us:

         I will withdraw: but this intrusion shall
        Now seeming sweet convert to bitter gall.

Immediately after, Romeo begins the sonnet that leads to the two lovers’ first kiss, and the next time we see speaks isn’t until Act 3.

However, a vital, unspoken, thematic development would naturally occur following Tybalt’s humiliation at his uncle’s command, namely: Tybalt would have followed Romeo for the rest of the party (and possibly beyond).  A character with the nickname as indicative as “Fiery Tybalt” would feel absolutely compelled, from both duty and personal loathsomeness towards Romeo, to tail him, to assure, exactly, how Romeo would "fleer and scorn" the Capulets.  In tailing Romeo it is certain Tybalt would have witnessed the new couple's first kiss.

This possibility of Tybalt witnessing Romeo and Juliet’s first kiss pivots on the meaning of Tybalt’s “I will withdraw."  Tybalt’s use of the verb “withdraw” may suggest that he leaves the stage, and is thus unable to see the action between Romeo and Juliet.

However, this verb is used in various Shakespeare works to indicate that, rather than leaving the stage, a character simply withdraws to one side of the primary action, yet is still able to witness the events occurring main stage. 

We see such an action in the play Othello, when Iago instructs Othello to hide and watch how Cassio reacts to Iago’s prodding.  Iago asks Othello “will you withdraw?," at which point Othello withdraws away from the main action, yet is still present to witness the exchange between Iago and Cassio. 

This use of the verb withdraw to indicate a character leaving the main action yet still present to witness the main action is employed in the play Hamlet, as well.  For instance, when Polonius and Claudius wish to snoop on Hamlet.  On the main stage, the two men hear Hamlet approaching, Polonius says, “I hear him coming: let's withdraw, my lord,” and the two move away from the main action, yet staying close enough to be able to witness the developing interaction between Hamlet and Ophelia. 

Tybalt’s use of withdraw is similar to this, he will withdraw away from the main action to follow Romeo, and thus to witness the beginnings of Romeo and Juliet’s love.

If Tybalt does in fact do what anyone with his fiery temperament would naturally do, he certainly would have witnessed Romeo and Juliet’s first kiss, and would be aghast at the budding romance.  Yet, he is impotent to do anything about it, having been ordered by an intoxicated and spiteful Uncle to keep the peace.

But, why doesn’t Tybalt inform Lord Capulet of what he has witnessed?  Tybalt has just seen an incredible sight, an abomination, the daughter of his uncle being molested by the son of the family’s enemy. Why not make this known?

Because, not only is Tybalt fiery, he is also vindictive.  He will lord over his domineering uncle with his secret knowledge. He will feed off this colossal secret, forcing his uncle’s future humiliation.  Withholding this secret, Tybalt claims power over his uncle, an asymmetrical epistemological hierarchy is established with Tybalt on top.  In this way, Tybalt attempts to assuage the shame and humiliation he’s just suffered at the hands of his uncle, that same shame and humiliation he speaks of when facing Romeo the following day,

                           …this shall not excuse the injuries
        that thou hast done me. Therefore turn and draw.

Tybalt has been so humiliated by his uncle, that he can only focus on the shame and humiliation that he himself feels ("that thou hast done me"), egotistically structuring Romeo’s trespass to be not against his uncle, or the family in general, but against Tybalt himself.  Too, he feels the humiliation to be so deeply personal that he does not even think to voice protection of Juliet’s integrity, having seen what has transpired between she and Romeo the previous night. 

Tybalt's disgraced ego cannot see beyond its own insulted state, and the resulting secret, intentionally withheld from his uncle, gives Tybalt a more proactive role, more agency and thus more complicity in the unfolding tragedy.  

Comments